Question: Does TCGA data represents whole population
gravatar for David_emir
9 days ago by
David_emir300 wrote:


I am working on TCGA Datasets and have few questions regarding this. My work is mainly involved around identifying genes which are disease-causing, i.e directly or by secondary activation. going forward, I have few doubts and need your opinion on the following

  1. Can TCGA datasets be used to predict prognosis for Indian Population as well? (Results from the TCGA analysis) since all samples are sourced from a particular geographic location - Demographic differences.
  2. What sample size is the best sample size? or How much is good or how much is too much. your opinion/ view on this is valuable and It would be really helpful if you can assist me in any kind of literature available on this.

Thanks a lot for your kind help.


PS: I am a non-native English speaker, Please pardon any mistakes.

tcga • 106 views
ADD COMMENTlink written 9 days ago by David_emir300

Someone will be along with more precise answers but from my general understanding.

  1. That is hard to say. I don't think there are any direct Indian samples in TCGA dataset. There may be samples of people of Indian origin who reside in the US.
  2. India being the second most populous country would likely require a very large sample size to truly represent the actual population.
ADD REPLYlink modified 9 days ago • written 9 days ago by genomax59k

Here is some work that goes over the different ethnic groups in TCGA:

I think it likely that Indians from India are grouped with 'Asian', so, numbers are probably extremely low. One could determine ethnicity by taking the TCGA genotype data and plotting it against 1000 Genomes, as I do here: Produce PCA bi-plot for 1000 Genomes Phase III - Version 2

1000 Genomes has:

  • Gujarati Indian from Houston, Texas
  • Indian Telugu from the UK

However, doing that is a large project and could take weeks / months.

ADD REPLYlink written 9 days ago by Kevin Blighe33k

Thanks a lot, Kevin, one quick question, can we treat Diaspora on par with Native Population? I mean, if 2nd generations Indians/Asians(Who were born in the US) staying in the US for a very long time then can we treat them alike? Thanks a lot, Kevin.

ADD REPLYlink modified 9 days ago • written 9 days ago by David_emir300

If one were to look at it logically, how much does a genome change over two generations?

ADD REPLYlink written 9 days ago by RamRS19k

Hi Ram Thanks for the reply, maybe not that much to change into new species. But there will be some changes, some mutations, which might be commonly not seen in native populations because of so many reasons like Environment, Diet change, etc. I might be wrong but This thought in me is pricking from inside. Thanks, RamRs

ADD REPLYlink written 9 days ago by David_emir300

I'm trying to understand your point, David_emir. But it feels unnatural to think that a bunch of Indians that moved to the US might see significant changes in their germline DNA within a couple of generations. The way we can answer this is to figure out how 1000g stratified individuals, such as their verification of lineage (are these Indians an offspring of another Indian that moved to the US and had a child with a non-Indian) and of the omics dimension (are we looking at the genome, epigenome or the gut microbiome?).

But yeah, it would be an interesting exercise to see if any of the TCGA samples cluster with 1000g SAS samples in PCA.

ADD REPLYlink modified 8 days ago • written 8 days ago by RamRS19k
Please log in to add an answer.


Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy.
Powered by Biostar version 2.3.0
Traffic: 839 users visited in the last hour