Question: Arlequin Significant Fst Values For Population Sizes N=1, Do Not Match Genodive Fst Values
0
gravatar for luckylion07
6.4 years ago by
luckylion0730
luckylion0730 wrote:

Hello,

I did calculate Fst values with 3 microsatellite makers for 29 populations using Arlequin 3.5.1.3 (Population pairwise Fst values: Compute F-statistics on haplotype frequencies only). However I have a population "A" with only one individual. Fst values of "A" compared to other populations shows significant p-values (p<0.05). How is that possible? I did check the input file, no problem there. From what I learned, sample sizes of n=1 can never be significant.

Also I calculated Fst values with GenoDive, wich is leading to slightly different Fst values (mean diference 0.0151, sd=0.0699).

Can you please confirm or comment on, if significant values for population sizes n=1 are valid?

If some one has a suggestion for a alternative program that can calculate different varieties of Fst with p-values i would be very happy! Thank you for your time!

here a part of the input file for arlequin:

[Profile]
  Title = "..." 
  NbSamples = 29
  GenotypicData = 1
  LocusSeparator = WHITESPACE
  GameticPhase = 1  # = unknown gametic phase
  MissingData = '?'
  CompDistMatrix = 1
  DataType = STANDARD

[Data]

[[Samples]]
    SampleName = "BB" 
    SampleSize = 1
    SampleData = {
    BB_01   1  175  300  168
               175  300  168
    }

    SampleName = "E03" 
    SampleSize = 20
    SampleData = {
    E03_01  1  177  300  164
               177  300  168
    E03_02  1    ?    ?  164
                 ?    ?  164
... continues
population genetics fst • 5.5k views
ADD COMMENTlink modified 6.4 years ago by Zev.Kronenberg11k • written 6.4 years ago by luckylion0730
0
gravatar for Zev.Kronenberg
6.4 years ago by
United States
Zev.Kronenberg11k wrote:

Fst is a score. You permute alleles to get an empirical P-value. You can run Fst for an individual, but you shouldn't invest too much faith in the output. With only one individual it becomes almost binary in nature.

The P-value is correct, but what does that mean? Not much.

ADD COMMENTlink written 6.4 years ago by Zev.Kronenberg11k
Please log in to add an answer.

Help
Access

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy.
Powered by Biostar version 2.3.0
Traffic: 1821 users visited in the last hour