what's the genomic location and name of gene responsible for orange and black patches in calico cats
Entering edit mode
29 days ago
Ann ★ 2.4k

Hi all,

I'm looking for help finding the name and genomic location for the gene that causes orange and black patches of fur in calico cats.

The gene is on the X chromosome, but that's all I know about it at this point.

If somebody could help me with this, I would appreciate it.

For your reference, here is a picture of the X chromosome from the "felCat9" genome assembly in Integrated Genome Browser. The data are from the UCSC JSON web service.

genome browser view of X chromosome from a cat genome assembly

Thanks a lot!

-Ann Loraine

genomes • 791 views
Entering edit mode

According to ChatGPT: The gene responsible for the orange and black patches of fur in calico cats (and tortoiseshell cats) is the X-linked gene for coat color called the "O" gene or the "O locus."

The O gene has two alleles:

O (Orange): This allele codes for orange pigment (phaeomelanin). Cats with one or two copies of the O allele will have orange patches in their fur.

o (Non-Orange): This allele codes for non-orange pigment (eumelanin, which can be black or gray). Cats with the o allele will have black or gray patches in their fur.

Because the O gene is located on the X chromosome, male cats (XY) can only be either orange or black, but not both, since they have only one X chromosome. However, female cats (XX) can have both orange and black patches due to X-chromosome inactivation, resulting in the unique calico or tortoiseshell pattern.

Entering edit mode

As far as I know the Orange locus hasn't been mapped to a gene. Maybe this paper will help in narrowing the search: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2666509

Entering edit mode

If GPT is right then it says that:

The specific gene responsible for the orange and non-orange (black or gray) fur colors in cats is the TYR gene, which codes for the enzyme tyrosinase. The O locus in cats is an allele of the TYR gene.

Following two papers are referred

Lyons, L. A. (2010). Genetic testing in domestic cats. Molecular and Cellular Probes, 24(5), 267-279.
Robinson, R. (2012). Genetics of coat colour and pattern in domestic cats. Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, 14(7), 448-457.

TYR seems to be onChrD1 so GPT could be hallucinating.

Entering edit mode

It is not entirely off, but evidently also not correct.

Melanin biosynthesis is a multistep process, that indeed prominently involves the Tyrosinase (E.C. enzyme, a copper‐containing metalloenzyme that catalyzes a sequence of redox reactions: First, the hydroxylation of L-tyrosine to L‐DOPA and subsequently the oxididation to L-dopaquinone.

Since L-dopaquinone is a common precursor of both, pheomelanin and eumelanin, Tyrosinase does not explain the orange or black fur colors. It is the rate-limiting step, so gene variants with lower efficacy and expression in melanosomes will reduce the overall melanin production and thus result in lighter-colored skin & hair, both in humans and cats. A complete loss of function of the Tyrosinase causes albinism.

Without knowing anything specifically about the genetic basis of cat fur coloring, I presume that the melanocortin-1 receptor (MC1R), that is responsible for the red hair in humans, is also somehow implied in the cat. There are however other processes, e.g. the availability of cysteine, which is required for pheomelanin to form that could hyptothetically influence the balance of pheomelanin vs. eumelanin. So I would suspect something along this axis - without doubt, the orange patches are essentially only colored with pheomelanin.

Entering edit mode

Given that you can never be completely sure they're not hallucinating, large language models still seem really poorly suited for these kinds of fact-summarizing tasks.  When would you know for sure that you trust the glob of text ChatGPT gave you?  When you see citations?  That won't do because those papers may not even exist, but even if they do, the papers may not support the statement, so you have to read through them anyway.

In this case Lyon's paper does sort of exist (though two years later than what it said) but only mentions TYR within a single table in the context of brown pigmentation.  The only relevant text that even mentions calico coloration talks about sex chromosome aberrations, which makes perfect sense given what actual sources say about where the coloration comes from (for example, this book chapter mentions the X-linked aspect for "Gene O" which backs up what you originally quoted from ChatGPT) but there are no real details about calico genetics in the Lyons paper.  I also can't find the Robinson paper at all.  So, go figure, ChatGPT made a false statement with mostly fictional references with the one sort-of-reference not backing up its statement anyway.

ChatGPT is mad libs at industrial scale. The words might say something true or they might not, but keep in mind that meaning doesn't factor into how it operates at all.


Login before adding your answer.

Traffic: 1411 users visited in the last hour
Help About
Access RSS

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy.

Powered by the version 2.3.6