Question: Gene-Disease Associations From Mass Spec Data
0
gravatar for syntonic.c
5.1 years ago by
syntonic.c10
United States
syntonic.c10 wrote:

Hi everyone. I'm still new to the kinds of analysis I have been doing and would appreciate a second opinion to verify my approach.

I have mass spec protein expression data obtained under various experimental conditions. In an earlier thread I was figuring out how to represent this data visually and I got some great suggestions; I eventually chose to use Cytoscape to map the proteins to GO terms and make an enriched network. Now that I can pull a bunch of genes out of various related GO categories, I want to compare them to gene databases for known genes associated to a particular disease. Let's use Autism as an example.

Using databases for autism-related genes such as SFARI, am able to pull out a gene list and then compare it to the list of genes that I got from my mass spec data. The point of this is to verify our experimental approach to show that our data - though not experimentally confirmed for a particular gene - can be used as a tool to narrow in on genes of interest for various diseases to give a direction for researchers to look (it's a bit more complicated than that but that is the general idea).

Question 1: Is my overall approach of simply comparing a list of putative autism-related genes to our dataset valid? Is there any pitfall to this kind of approach I should be aware of?

Question 2: Not all genes in a particular database may be the best candidates for that diseases. One example of this is this Alzheimer's database which has ~500 genes. However, they have a top 10 list. Is it better to compare my genes with the entire database or just the top 10?

Question 3: All of the genes I have are from rats. Some of the gene lists have a mixture of different model organisms. Is it valid to cross-compare genes between model organisms? I understand that the data I have is not verified by other experimental approaches, but in terms of leading research in a particular direction, is it okay to compare disease-related genes across species like this?

Question 4: There are sometimes multiple databases out there for a particular disease. How do I decide which ones to use for my comparison? Are some better than others? How do I figure out something like this?

Any basic information or clarification would greatly be appreciated. I just want to be very careful so I'd appreciate a second opinion. Thank you.

disease • 1.7k views
ADD COMMENTlink written 5.1 years ago by syntonic.c10
Please log in to add an answer.

Help
Access

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy.
Powered by Biostar version 2.3.0
Traffic: 2491 users visited in the last hour